Having waited until the international break to change coaches after a dismal start to the season that has left them in the relegation zone, Manchester United did the most Manchester United thing possible. That’s right, they went and hired a national team coach who wasn’t immediately available. Although his appointment was made official last week, Mauricio Pochettino will only move to Old Trafford after the United States’ CONCACAF Nations League quarter-final tie against Haiti. As a result, he will immediately find himself facing a run of seven fixtures in three weeks to begin his tenure.

A lack of time on the training ground will surely be a challenge for the new coach going into the busiest time of year, but it likely won’t be the biggest issue for Pochettino at United. All indications seem to suggest that he will have a hard time getting to grips with the ever-evolving tactical meta of the English Premier League, meaning he does not look likely to enjoy long-term success in Manchester.

Success in a different tactical era

Much of Pochettino’s reputation was built during his time in England in the 2010s, when he first led Southampton to the top half in his first season in the Premier League before making Tottenham Hotspur Champions League regulars and even taking them very close to an elusive major trophy.

When the Argentine coach first arrived on the shores of Great Britain in 2013, English football was in a very different place. Alex Ferguson was at the end of his tenure at Manchester United, with fans still wholeheartedly believing they were supporting an inevitably successful club. Perhaps more importantly, the football analytics bubble was very much in its nascent days, to the point that xG was only just starting to take hold as a critical and readily available metric.

With that in mind, it should not come as too much of a surprise that Pochettino’s Southampton wowed onlookers with their defensive intensity and novel tactics of ‘pressing’, not to be confused with the good old fashioned English approach of closing your man down. In all seriousness, the Saints definitely went against the league’s tactical meta in this regard. Colin Trainor’s primer on PPDA – the now ubiquitous metric to measure pressing intensity – cited Pochettino as “one of the poster boys for the high press” and pointed out that the Premier League had the highest average PPDA among Europe’s big five leagues in each of the last seasons. Spain – where Pochettino was coming from – was at the other end of the table in his last full season there.

Pressing intensity among Europe’s big five league in the early 2010s, as calculated by Colin Trainor in the aforementioned piece.

The former Espanyol coach continued to enjoy success through his side’s high degree of out-of-possession intensity at Tottenham Hotspur. While the league’s tactical meta generally moved towards a higher pressing approach in the later 2010s – accelerated by the arrival of the likes of Jürgen Klopp and Pep Guardiola to table-topping sides – pressing wasn’t the highest priority for most coaches. As it happened, it was right around the time that Pochettino left England that everything changed.

The ultimate catalyst for the pressing revolution was the tweak to the goal kick rule ahead of the 2019/20 season. There was a time when no one but the goalkeeper was allowed inside the box to restart play, and the ball was only considered in play when it exited the penalty area. Following the regulation change, it was no longer necessary to punt goal kicks up the field; you could retain the ball while building out from the back. In response, the side out of possession would at least have to set up higher up the pitch to start, encouraging more teams from all over the table to work on their presses.

Determined to retain possession, coaches started to work on coordinated build-up patterns to bypass or beat the high press. Consequently, such restarts have become a sort of set-play in themselves, with different pressing strategies such as zonal, player-oriented and hybrid developing for the team without the ball to coordinate their movements, while the side building up also had different routes to maintain possession and attack.

As a result of all of these developments, a merely intense press became inadequate. In fact, it now often is a weakness, as some sides look to press-bait to draw an opponent out and slice them open with quick forward passes. So, the biggest edge that Pochettino’s coaching gave his sides in the 2010s has not only eroded over the 2020s, but it has also become a potential weakness.

Challenges at Chelsea

Pochettino’s next role after leaving Tottenham came at Paris Saint-Germain, but that truly was more of a management job than a coaching assignment. He joined midway through the latest Ligue 1 season in which PSG did not end up as champions, to which they responded by adding Lionel Messi to an attack that already included Kylian Mbappé and Neymar.

The Argentine then returned to London to take charge of Chelsea in 2023/24, and found himself a much-changed Premier League for the aforementioned reasons. Yet, it was also very different to the league we know today. As a result of more prevalent high pressing and an increased appetite for risk-taking in the build-up, fast transitions and end-to-end action were the orders of the day. The English top-flight saw 3.28 goals per game that term – the highest average in close to six decades. Pochettino’s Chelsea were all-in with this open and transition-heavy approach, putting up an average of 3.68 goals in their games, trailing only Eddie Howe’s Newcastle United.

There were some merits to this approach; summer signing Cole Palmer put up 22 goals and 11 assists in his best league campaign to date, while Nicolas Jackson also achieved a career-high of 14 league goals. They contributed to placing Chelsea among the league’s best attacks despite a slow start to the season in front of goal, but the defence wasn’t nearly as good. The Blues were on the lower side of mid-table for both goals and xG conceded, as Pochettino’s high press got sliced open on a few occasions, and their rest defence often did not hold up too well. Consequently, they often had to stay more disciplined in a mid block, but they weren’t the most solid in this phase either, and could not execute their coach’s favoured style of play to its fullest.

The mitigating factor amid all of this was BlueCo’s increasingly insane player trading at Chelsea, but more so than results and a failure to finish in the top four, United fans should be concerned by the specific on-pitch issues Pochettino’s side faced that term. Patrick and I discussed those in some more detail on the podcast last week.

Quick fixes and potential issues at Manchester United

Despite all the concerns I have been elaborating on, it is quite clear that Pochettino should be able to get more out of this Manchester United squad in the short term. As I have pointed out many times on this newsletter, they were absolutely woeful defensively under Michael Carrick this season, so there are relatively easy improvements to be made in that respect by just putting together a competent defensive block. Moreover, the Red Devils’ fitness levels have looked insufficient at times even after the opening weeks of the season. That is exactly the kind of negative energy that Pochettino and his lemons won’t stand for.

After the new manager bounce, though, the ride could quickly start to get bumpy. The Argentine coach demands a good deal from his full-backs, but the options in United’s squad don’t look too attractive. Patrick Dorgu is probably best suited to the flank-running role that Pochettino likes, but his recent injury record makes for concerning reading and he may not always be dependable in defence. Luke Shaw’s fitness is another big concern, Nouassair Mazroui lacks some of the physical attributes his new coach prefers, and Diogo Dalot’s recent form has been driving fans mad (though he has been playing on the wrong side).

The current United squad and their latest coach share a preference towards attacking in transition. This could make them an effective block-and-counter team in the short term, but they may also start getting frustrated against deeper blocks before long. The Premier League has once again changed a lot since Pochettino was last here; structural integrity in defence is back in fashion and end-to-end track meets are much harder to come by.

Finding the right balance in midfield may well be the biggest overarching challenge, since United lack well-rounded players in this part of the pitch. Pochettino likes his midfielders to both be physically imposing and dictate play on the ball, but he will find himself having to pick between one or the other for most of his selections. Even in his most recent job in charge of the USMNT, the Argentine coach’s relative success came from being able to overrun a lot of opponents in the middle of the park. Doing so is far harder in the Premier League – especially with this United squad – so he will need to show different ideas if he is to succeed in Manchester.

If you enjoyed this newsletter, we’d appreciate it if you would forward it to a friend. If you’re that friend, welcome! You can subscribe to The Transfer Flow here. We also have a podcast where we go in depth on transfer news and rumours every week. We’re on YouTube here, and you can subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Spotify by searching for “The Transfer Flow Podcast.” If you’re interested in football betting, check out this post on why we started Variance Betting.